diff --git a/plugins/win-capture/duplicator-monitor-capture.c b/plugins/win-capture/duplicator-monitor-capture.c
index abc38ef8b..a898632d8 100644
--- a/plugins/win-capture/duplicator-monitor-capture.c
+++ b/plugins/win-capture/duplicator-monitor-capture.c
@@ -661,7 +661,7 @@ static obs_properties_t *duplicator_capture_properties(void *data)
 	obs_property_list_add_int(p, TEXT_METHOD_AUTO, METHOD_AUTO);
 	obs_property_list_add_int(p, TEXT_METHOD_DXGI, METHOD_DXGI);
 	obs_property_list_add_int(p, TEXT_METHOD_WGC, METHOD_WGC);
-	obs_property_list_item_disable(p, 1, !capture->wgc_supported);
+	obs_property_list_item_disable(p, 2, !capture->wgc_supported);
 	obs_property_set_modified_callback(p, display_capture_method_changed);
 
 	obs_property_t *monitors = obs_properties_add_list(